Relishments

Savoring life in the Berkshires

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Relishments Around the Web
  • Flexitarianism
    • Cookbooks
  • Recipes
    • Recipe Reviews
  • The Berkshires
    • Boothbay, Midcoast Maine and More
    • Adventures in Other Places
  • Technology
    • My Favorite Technology Tools
  • Contact
    • Sponsor

#50: Make Pierogies From Scratch

Published on January 9, 2014 By Emily. Updated on January 11, 2014

Last October, I published a post detailing my progress on my 101 in 1001 list.  Number 50 on that list was “make pierogies from scratch”.  My mother-in-law responded, volunteering to make them with me next time we were together and, over Christmas, we were finally able to make that happen.

As I’ve mentioned in the past, pierogies are pretty important to my husband’s family.  His father’s side is Ukranian and his dad has childhood memories of helping his grandmother prepare them.  Pierogies are always part of Christmas breakfast in Brian’s family.  I’ve never had them (or really heard of them) before I met Brian but since then I’ve really learned to like them.  Coincidentally we’re also living in an area with a historically Polish population, so our supermarkets always carry multiple brands and local churches and organizations sell them for fundraisers.  We always have pierogies in our freezer; they’re perfect for making when there isn’t a lot of time or options.  They also go on sale at the supermarket regularly, so that helps.

Even though it was my first time making pierogies, we didn’t slack on this project.  My mother-in-law did most of the work, choosing recipes and preparing 2 fillings before I arrived at her house for the holidays.  Some pierogies were to be filled with plain potato filling, some with potato/onion/cheese filling and some with cabbage filling.  My contribution was bringing a cabbage from our CSA.

We began by making the dough, using this Martha Stewart recipe.  It was a pretty basic dough recipe that included a little bit of sour cream — we used 3 tablespoons of sour cream instead of 2.  We made the dough, shaped it into a ball, then placed it under an inverted bowl, as per the instructions.

IMG_2802

The next part of the project was preparing the cabbage filling.  For this we greatly reduced a recipe from the Martha Stewart cookbook, using my two pounds of cabbage instead of the ten pounds required originally.  We did not need to make eight dozen cabbage pierogies.  The cabbage was chopped, steamed, squeezed of all liquid and then chopped in the food processor.  Next we mixed it with cream cheese and salt and pepper.

IMG_2804

cabbage pierogi filling

With the fillings ready to go, it was time to assemble the pierogies.  We used a quarter of the dough at a time, leaving the rest under the bowl.   We quickly determined that the best way to get things done would be to alternate roles: one of us rolled out the dough and cut the rounds while the other filled and closed the pierogies, then we switched.  The dough was incredibly elastic and we were able to get about 10 rounds from each section of dough.  It certainly took a little time to get the hang of things, but overall I feel like it went pretty smoothly.  I was really impressed with how much the dough could stretch without breaking.  To keep from confusing the three types of pierogies, we closed each variety of dumpling differently.  Cabbage pierogies were closed with fork tines, plain potato pierogies had pleated closures and the potato and cheese pierogies had plain closures.

IMG_2809

Using the advice from the recipe, we froze the pierogies by laying them on cookie sheets and transferring them to storage bags after they were frozen.  The cookie sheets we filled after this photo was taken were lined with waxed paper which made the pierogies much easier to remove from the pan.  We ended up with leftover filling for all of the varieties and about 40 pierogies all together.  We would have had more if we’d used all the dough, but we found that it was really tough even as early as a second roll so we were only able to get one set of rounds from each quarter of dough.

IMG_2811

The next morning the four of us (Brian and I and his parents) traveled to visit Brian’s brother and sister-in-law, pierogies in tow.  The dumplings went straight from the freezer into pots of boiling water where they cooked until they floated.

frozen pierogies

cooking pierogies

IMG_2816

If leftovers are any indication, these pierogies went over very well.  Despite the amount of other food on the table, there was not a single pierogi left after dinner.  These pierogies definitely had a thinner dough then the ones I usually buy at the store and they stuck together somewhat during cooking, but they were very delicious. I was also very pleased with how well they held up during cooking. It was fun to eat fillings other than the ones I tend to buy.  Making pierogies was definitely a lot of work and I’m very glad I had my mother-in-law to help me.  It was a lot of fun to have someone to work with and our assembly line method of filling the pierogies made the project go much more quickly.  Making pierogies from scratch probably won’t be a regular thing for me, especially given their local availability, but I’m really glad I made these.

Related Posts

Cranberry, Lime & Coconut Loaf…from Pin...
#43: Go to a wine tasting
#45: Making a Birthday Cake from Scratch
101 in 1001: (Less Than) One Year to Go
Did you enjoy this post? Share it!

Filed Under: recipe review Tagged With: 101 in 1001

« Twosday XII: Back to the Routine
When in Doubt: What to Get From a Winter CSA or Farmers’ Market »

Comments

  1. Carol Pious says

    January 10, 2014 at 12:33 pm

    Emily – I too am glad we made them together. Great fun! Carol

Trackbacks

  1. » Vegetable Tetrazzini says:
    January 14, 2014 at 8:12 pm

    […] week I shared my experience making pierogies for the first time.  This week I’m posting about another food that Brian exposed me to: […]

  2. » 101 in 1001: The Final Tally says:
    October 2, 2014 at 7:43 pm

    […] Surprise my coworkers with baked goods (December 2013)50.  Make pierogies from scratch (Christmas 2013)51.  Grow my own tomatoes (2013)52.  Host a cookie swap (2/10/2012)53.  Can jelly or […]

Welcome!

Welcome to Relishments! Follow along with my adventures in flexitarian eating and cooking in the Berkshires of Western Massachusetts.

The Berkshires
Recipe Index
CSA Menu Plan
First Time?
 

Support Relishments on Patreon

Just so you know…

I’m just a girl who loves to cook and eat. This site is not a source for nutritional information.

Relishments is affiliated with various sponsors. Some product links on this site are affiliates; I may get portion of the sale. All opinions on this site are honest, regardless of revenue opportunities. Find out more about my policies here

Relishments is affiliated with…

View my food journey on Zomato!

  
Ahalogy Badge

relishments

After months of good intentions, I finally got aro After months of good intentions, I finally got around to making Change Your Life Chicken from @thelazygenius. It totally lived up the the hype: super crispy chicken skin, flavorful vegetables that didn't burn, and a recipe that was easy and largely hands off. I'll be adding this one to the regular rotation.
.
.
.
#thelazygenius #changeyourlifechicken #sheetpanmeals #chickendinner #dinner #homecooking
Happy first day of spring! It actually felt like s Happy first day of spring! It actually felt like spring here, which was lovely. In addition to playing in the yard and going for walks, we enjoyed dinner from @aokberkshirebbq. Pictured is their excellent sausage sandwich (left), brisket sandwich (right) and potato salad. So delicious.
.
.
.
#igers413_food
#igers413 #BerkshireFoodies #InTheBerkshires #EatLocal #WesternMA #WesternMass #VisitTheBerkshires
#NorthAdams #NAmazing #MeatMeInNorthAdams #AOKBerkshireBBQ #eatlocal #barbecue #Berkshires
When @wholefully announced their new #MakeItWholef When @wholefully announced their new #MakeItWholefully Cooking Club, I immediately got excited about participating. My excitement increased when I saw that the recipe for this quarter is Easy Chicken Quesadillas. These quesadillas are so much better than what I usually make. I'm not sure if the taco seasoning (I don't usually add cumin to mine), the fresh bell peppers or the burrito-sized tortillas, but this recipe makes a quesadilla that  reminds me of eating at restaurants. (Remember eating at restaurants?) Everyone in my household loved this recipe and I will definitely be making it again. 
.
.
.
You can participate in this round of the Make It Whole fully Cooking Club until March 31.
.
.
.
#quesadilla #wholefully #DinnerIdeas
In January I decided that one of my "deliberate" s In January I decided that one of my "deliberate" sub-goals for 2021 would be to figure out the best pizza dough recipe and topping combinations for my family. We've had pizza night on the menu for a long time, but I knew that I could improve the pizzas that were coming out of my oven. Each week (or so) I've been sharing in my Stories the pizzas I've made with various stores and toppings. I am eight weeks in I've already learned a lot about technique and what I prefer in a pizza crust and toppings. I'm also looking forward to seeing what the rest of the year will hold in my pizza making studies. Check out my highlights for all the pizzas so far!
.
.
.
#pizza #homemadepizza #goals #resolutions
New year, new word! This year, I'm focusing on bei New year, new word!
This year, I'm focusing on being deliberate in my speech, my relationships, my work and my time. Change isn't going to happen my chance!
More of my thoughts are on the blog, link in my profile.
.
.
.
#onelittleword #myoneword #newyears #newyearsresolution #2021 #2021theme
My top 9 of 2020. In typical 2020 fashion, I had a My top 9 of 2020.
In typical 2020 fashion, I had all kinds of issues getting my Top 9 created this year and this image still has problems. 
But the images are accurate and nicely summarize the year - take out from local establishments (@aokberkshirebbq, @thebreakroomgw, @northadamsfarmersmarket), #RelishmentsBakes projects, the natural beauty of the Berkshires and our successful container garden.
.
.
.
#topnine2020 #2020 #newyear
New on the blog: my 8 favorite recipes I made in 2 New on the blog: my 8 favorite recipes I made in 2020. This post has ideas for every meal and features recipes from @bonappetitmag, @kingarthurbaking, @budgetbytes, @markbittman, @smittenkitchen and @wholefully.
.
Link in profile.
.
I'd love to hear about the best things you cooked this year!
.
.
.
#recipe #recipereview #favoriterecipe
Apparently, in the weirdness that is 2020, posting Apparently, in the weirdness that is 2020, posting to my Instagram feed was one of the things that didn't make the cut. There are more items than I'd prefer in that category, but recently I've felt like I'm beginning to get my feet firmly planted beneath me again. This fall was so busy with learning how to teach remotely and parent 2 children well. I don't anticipate that life will ever feel not busy, but I've been able to carve out some time lately for activities I've been missing. Making bread is one of those activities. Hopefully, more posts in the feed will be more frequent going forward. 
.
.
.
Peasant bread recipe from @breadin5
For last month's #RelishmentBakes challenge I made For last month's #RelishmentBakes challenge I made apple turnovers with puff pastry from scratch. I am so pleased with how well they turned out and proud of myself for tackling puff pastry.  Get all the details at the link in my profile. Next month's challenge is coming soon!
.
.
.
#BakingChallenge #BakingFromScratch #bakealong #turnovers #AppleTurnovers
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2021 · Foodie Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in