Relishments

Savoring life in the Berkshires

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • About
    • Start Here
    • Relishments Around the Web
    • Flexitarianism
      • Cookbooks
  • Recipes
    • Recipe Reviews
  • The Berkshires
    • Boothbay, Midcoast Maine and More
    • Adventures in Other Places
  • Contact
    • Sponsor

Vegetarianism: An Eating Disorder?

Published on April 7, 2009 By Emily. Updated on April 7, 2009

From Time: Study: Is Vegetarianism a Teen Eating Disorder?

As soon as I saw this headline, I was annoyed.  I’m no longer a teenager, but I certainly identify with them in a lot of ways, never mind the fact that I work with hundreds of them on a daily basis.  On one hand, it shouldn’t have taken the Journal of the American Dietetic Association to tell us that vegetarianism isn’t always healthy. Clearly, that isn’t limited to just teenagers. It takes a lot of work and effort to be a healthy vegetarian. But eating like a “normal” teenager and consuming bags of potato chips isn’t healthy either. Unfortunately, according to this study

it seems that a significant number of kids experiment with vegetarian diets as a way to mask their eating disorders, since it’s a socially acceptable way to avoid eating many foods and one that parents tend not to oppose.

That said, I think we must be careful not to assume that the findings of this study apply to all vegetarian teenagers. It was teenagers who “converted” me to eating less meat to begin with and the teen vegetarians I know are healthy students, one of whom has the possibility of going to the Olympics (seriously).

We must not ignore the fact that the study found that “in one sense, vegetarians were healthier.”  Furthermore, only 4.8% of the students surveyed reported that they were currently vegetarian, which means the study found that 1.2% of the surveyed  youth were vegetarians who “had engaged in extreme weight-control measures.”  I think we must be very careful not to assume that all, or even most, teen vegetarians are doing so for the wrong reasons.  Vegetarianism is becoming increasingly popular and it’s only to be expected that more teens will be changing their eating habits.  I take issue with the article’s title: it seems vegetarianism itself isn’t the eating disorder, though teens may use it as a way to mask other issues.  The authors suggest that “parents and doctors should be extra vigilant when teens suddenly become vegetarians.” In my opinion, parents should be vigilant and pay attention to all lifestyle changes a teen makes, but it’s clear to me that eating a diet which focuses on consuming fruits, vegetables, legumes and grains over meat is better than the average American diet.  Finally,

The findings suggest that age matters when it comes to vegetarianism: teenage vegetarians as well as young experimenters — those who try it but abandon it — may be at higher risk for other eating disorders compared with their peers. But by young adulthood, many still-practicing vegetarians have presumably chosen it as a lifestyle rather than a dieting ploy, the study suggests.

Not all teen vegetarians may be doing so for the right reasons, but I think we must assume that is the exception, not the rule.  Those of us who are flexitarians (or vegetarians) must continue to educate youth about good nutrition, but I don’t think this study should cause those of us who know teen vegetarians to panic.

Related Posts

Needs Work:Rach’s Creamy Pasta with Spinach ...
Chickpeas, Take 2.
Time Magazine, DWTS, and Scientific Research: High...
Highlights: The BP Oil Spill
Did you enjoy this post? Share it!

Filed Under: internet Tagged With: news, vegetarian

« Lime Sugar Cookies with Pumpkin Seeds
'Food Snob' Quiz and Other Good News »

Comments

  1. Pious says

    April 7, 2009 at 9:17 am

    I could see where it gets the idea that vegetarianism “masks” eating disorders. Becoming vegetarian I feel is something that cannot just be “done” in a day; teenagers who decide it on a whim may simply be going through a phase and not make it a lasting life style.

    As an educator I need to keep an eye out for students with eating disorders, so now do I need to report all the vegetarian students I know?

  2. Shana says

    April 7, 2009 at 12:45 pm

    I started becoming a vegetarian before I hit my teens and yes it was sudden. I think 15 years ago was a different time and now-a-days, kids have a lot more knowledge about the subject, along with a lot more options. They also have a lot more pressure to start looking “good” at a younger age.

    Just the way that the TIME article spins this “fad” really irritates me. It is an important subject, but I think you hit it on the head when you said “parents should pay attention to all lifestyle changes a teen makes.” I am sure that sudden vegetarian isn’t the first sign of a problem.

  3. Law feminist says

    April 7, 2009 at 3:08 pm

    I became a vegetarian at 14, and 12 years later, I am still the healthiest person I know. I am more conscious of my protein intake than female friends who are concerned about their weight and consequently underconsume calories. I lift heavy weights regularly and run four or more miles a day. I have never had an eating disorder- on the contrary, I love food and cook all of my meals myself. The Time article made at best spurious conclusions as to the correlation between vegetarianism and health. Essentially, it read as one more ignorant attack on a lifestyle people have chosen not to understand.

  4. Pious says

    April 7, 2009 at 3:32 pm

    Okay you can all hate me but I must say something else:

    “The findings suggest that age matters when it comes to vegetarianism: teenage vegetarians as well as young experimenters — those who try it but abandon it — may be at higher risk for other eating disorders compared with their peers. But by young adulthood, many still-practicing vegetarians have presumably chosen it as a lifestyle rather than a dieting ploy, the study suggests.”

    In this brief quote the author states that it “suggests” does not prove one way or another. The article itself is simply putting a question forward, looks at some studies and gives different sides of the coins. Also, it does not appear to be his own conclusions, rather he is reporting about the findings of a number of studies. So if you wish to be “mad” at anyone talk to the “Journal of the American Dietetic Association”

    As not being a vegetarian or carnivore I can come to this article with a neutral perspective on this topic. I believe it is good to understand all sides, because in general we seem to assume vegetables are good so vegans and vegetarianism must have no downside. We must all know the downside and upside to be able to make a complete judgment. If you have lived the great healthy lifestyle as a vegetarian then you see no downside, but if you step back and look at all parts of the spectrum then you can make a better judgment. Sadly, some people will draw extreme conclusions or impose their own personal views and ruin the reporting of this fine glimpse at this question. John Cloud did not even scratch the surface of all that could be looked at on this topic.

Trackbacks

  1. teen eating disorders and vegetarianism? « says:
    April 7, 2009 at 1:16 pm

    […] Disorder? that really got under my skin.  After reading a blog post on the same article from relishments, I was even more irritated about the topic.  I became a vegetarian before I hit my teens and yes […]

  2. teen eating disorders and vegetarianism? | Paso Robles Wineries says:
    April 11, 2009 at 8:52 pm

    […] really got under my skin.  After reading a blog post on the same article from Emily Brunell of relishments, I was even more irritated about the topic.  I became a vegetarian before I hit my teens and yes […]

Welcome!

photo of EmilyWelcome to Relishments! Follow along with my adventures in cooking and eating in the Berkshires of Western Massachusetts.

The Berkshires
Recipe Index
CSA Menu Plan
First Time?
 

Support Relishments on Patreon

Just so you know…

I’m just a girl who loves to cook and eat. This site is not a source for nutritional information.

Relishments is affiliated with various sponsors. Some product links on this site are affiliates; I may get portion of the sale. All opinions on this site are honest, regardless of revenue opportunities. Find out more about my policies here

relishments

Emily
New year, new theme word! This year's word is "enr New year, new theme word!
This year's word is "enrich" and I'm really excited about it.

I've written more about this year's theme on the blog. Click in the link in my profile or follow the link below to read the post.
.
https://www.relishments.com/blog/my-2023-theme-word-enrich/
.
.
.
#YearlyTheme #MyOneWord #2023 #enrich2023 #NewYearsResolution
It's not New Year's Eve without a Top 9 post. It's It's not New Year's Eve without a Top 9 post.
It's almost all #Berkshires content this year, which is great.
1. A pasta salad reel that took longer to create than the recipe took to make.
2. A reel from North Carolina where I could have watched birds all day.
3. The @thelazygenius book giveaway.
4.@plantconnector 
5. @berkshiremuseum 
6.@sculpture.now at @themountlenox 
7. @massmoca 
8. @mountainviewfarm413 
9. The #AshuwillticookRailTrail
New on the blog: My 2022 reflections on last year' New on the blog: My 2022 reflections on last year's theme word - resume. 

I was able to get back to many activities that were meaningful to me this year and I'm calling this theme a success. Follow the link below or click the link in my profile to read more.
.
.
.
https://www.relishments.com/blog/reflections-on-resuming-in-2022/
.
#resume2022 #newyearsresolution #myoneword #yearlytheme
New on the blog: My Favorite Recipes of 2022. For New on the blog: My Favorite Recipes of 2022.

For the fourth year, I've recapped the best new (to me) recipes I made this year in the hope that they'll give you some new dishes to try. This year's list is short, but delicious. It includes @budgetbytes My Favorite Recipes of 2022
Published on December 30, 2022 By Emily. Updated on December 30, 2022

It’s hard to believe that 2022 is basically behind us. Though overall this year found me getting back to the person I want to be (post-babies and “post”-pandemic), I did not try nearly as many new recipes this year as I used to. In fact, I was pleasantly surprised to see that I’d made note of any new-to-me recipes I wanted to share in this post. This year’s list is short, but delicious. It includes recipes from @budgetbytes, @smittenkitchen and @howsweeteats.
.
.
.
Read the post by visiting the link in my profile or 
https://www.relishments.com/blog/my-favorite-recipes-of-2022/
.
.
.
#RecipeRoundUp #BestRecipes2022 #FavoriteRecipes
@coastalmainebotanicalgardens continues to be one @coastalmainebotanicalgardens continues to be one of the highlights of all my return trips to Boothbay and their annual Gardens Aglow event continues to impress. It was great to be back to walking the gardens instead of the pandemic drive through and there seemed to be more lights than ever.  I'm already looking forward to next year.
.
.
.
#Boothbay #BoothbayMaine #CoastalMaineBotanicalGardens #GardensAglow #BotanicalGarden #MidcoastMaine
It has been a while, but there is finally a new CS It has been a while, but there is finally a new CSA menu plan on the blog! Visit the link below or in my profile to see how I plan to make use of some of the @mightyfoodfarm produce seen here.
.
.
https://www.relishments.com/blog/welcome-to-winter-farm-share-csa-menu-plan-148/
.
#MightyFoodFarm #EatLocal #EatSeasonal #VermontGrown #CSApickup #CSAshare #KnowYourFarmerKnowYourFood #MenuPlanning #MealPlanning #igers413 #igers413_food #BerkshireFoodies
Fall in the Berkshires is always incredible, but t Fall in the Berkshires is always incredible, but this year we've had weather that has also been outstanding. The past 2 weekends have included time at Jaeschke Orchards, the Greylock Glen, and the Ashuwillticook Rail Trail as well as stopping to photograph any random foliage I see. 
Check out the last slide for video of some feathered friends we saw on a walk.
.
.
.
#igers413 #InTheBerkshires #EatLocal #WesternMA #WesternMass #Berkshires  #VisitTheBerkshires #FallFoliage #FallColors #autumn #AshuwillticookRailTrail #JaeschkeOrchards #GreylockGlen
@freshgrassfestival continues to be one of my favo @freshgrassfestival continues to be one of my favorite events each year, and it doesn't hurt that it's just minutes away from home. Enjoying the festival with my kids is definitely a different experience than without, but it's still a good time. The weather was especially cooperative today which was great for all the laps I did around the @massmoca campus pushing a stroller. I'm already looking forward to next year.
.
.
.
#igers413 #InTheBerkshires #WesternMA #WesternMass #Berkshires  #VisitTheBerkshires #NorthAdams #NAmazing #FreshGrass #FreshGrassFestival #MassMoCA #MusicFestival
A few more photos from our most recent trip to Mai A few more photos from our most recent trip to Maine:
- a foggy afternoon at Ocean Point
- kid-free lunch at @shannonsunshelled, followed by beers at @footbridge_brewery
- watching birds from my parent's deck
- dinner at @bucksnakedbbqsteakhouse and dessert at @gelatofiasco
- a hot dog and Belgian waffle sundae from @wannawaf
- a visit to the Boothbay Railway Village Museum, featuring an impressive model railroad
.
.
.
#VisitMaine #MidcoastMaine #Boothbay #BoothbayHarbor
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2023 · Foodie Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in